Friday, September 13, 2013

This Day In Gay Utah History SEPTEMBER 13

September 13th
Sugar House State Prison
1890  To the Pen for Two Years  Frank Wilson charged with the “Crime Against Nature” pleaded not guilty and C. W Boyd was appointed to defend him. Salt Lake Tribune page 5

1892  Fourth District  Taken To the Pen Marshal Gill took a trio of criminals to the penitentiary last evening the parties were Al Wood the colored porter who attempted to butcher Pat Boyle with a razor in a Twenty Fifth Street saloon and John Mack and James Warren charged with sodomy the latter pleaded guilty and was sentenced by Judge Anderson to six months imprisonment in the pen. Ogden Standard Examiner 1892-09-13 page  1
  • 1892 The People vs John Mack indictment sodomy pleaded not guilty and trial set for Sept 27. Deputy United States Marshal W F Gill went to Salt Lake last evening and took along with him to the penitentiary Al Wood, colored, charged with assault with intent to kill. James Warren and John Mack indicted for sodomy. Warren pleaded guilty and was sentenced to six months in the penitentiary
1941 Two men pleaded morals charges Saturday before Judge Baker The judge  set September 13 for sentencing of Asel Neilson, 22, Myton who pleaded guilty to a charge of assaulting a woman. The same date was set for trial off Hyrum B. Berkenpas 52 of 44 East Second South street who admitted to a charge of sodomy  Salt Lake Telegram
  • Hyrum B. Berkenpas 52 44 East Second South street convicted of sodomy was committed to prison for a term of from three to 20 years Salt Lake Telegram. On 15 Aug 1941 Hyrum B. Berkenpas of the Elk Hotel 44 East Second South Street SLC was charged with sodomy offense in a complaint signed by Detectives Jack E. Blazzard and W W. Clyde Smith. The suspect was remanded to county jail in lieu of bail. The detectives alleged Berkenpas enticed a 17 year-old Ohio youth to his room on August 14 and committed immoral acts. 
1967- A survey of Ogden’s bars, taverns, and night clubs released Tuesday by the American Social Health Association showed that prostitution in the city is almost negligible.  Ogden was once known for its dens of prostitution in 1942 when 11 houses were in operation along 3 blocks of 25th Street.

Billie Crystal
1974-The first national lesbian writer's convention was held in Chicago.

1977-"Soap" premiered on ABC. The comedy show included Billy Crystal as a Gay character, Jodie Dallas.1977 .

1977- Gay Service Coalition met at the home of Bill G. They discussed listing the Gay Help line phone number in the Bay Area Reporter of San Francisco.

Cloy Jenkins
1979- BYU’s Institute for Studies in Values and Human Behavior had not succeeded in achieving its goals. Allen Bergin and Victor Brown had not rebutted Cloy Jenkins’ Payne Papers. Bergin’s scholarly objectivity was challenged during professional conferences and his professional standing was being questioned. BYU President Dallin Oaks was annoyed at what he perceived to be an undermining of his own authority by members of the institute. On this date Oaks wrote Apostle Thomas Monson to explain the problems of the Bergin-Brown Book on Values and to inform church officials that school administrators had become persuaded “that we cannot achieve the original objectives to the extent hoped” by having the book appear through “independent popular publishers”

1980- Nineteen-year-old Andrew Exler filed suit against Disneyland after having been ejected for dancing with his male date a month earlier; eight years later, he won the case. On September 13, 1980 ("Date Night"), Andrew Axler  was disco dancing on the Tomorrowland Terrace dance floor with another teenage male (Shawn Elliott).  Five security officers physically brought us to a halt, processed us at the security office and escorted us from the park.  It wasn't until many years later that I learned the security office where we were detained is now referred to as the "Disneyland Jail." In 1984, a conservative Orange County jury found that Disneyland, under California law, violated our rights  based on sex or sexual orientation.  It was a landmark decision that made international news, and it was one of the first times a plaintiff won any type of case against the powerful Walt Disney Company, let alone one this controversial. No monetary damages were sought, but the way Disneyland now treats their gay guests and cast members has hopefully changed for the better. Immediately after the verdict, a Disneyland attorney insisted the jury verdict only applied to Shawn and I, and he vowed that Disneyland would "shut down the dance floors" before permitting other same-sex couples to dance together. Although the park immediately filed an appeal, they dropped it after my attorney (Ronald Talmo) won a landmark California Supreme Court case where the court held that business establishments violated state civil rights laws by offering 'Ladies Day' or 'Ladies Night' promotions (Koire v. Metro Car Wash).  Disney knew, based on the ruling in Koire, that if Exler v. Disneyland made its way to the California Supreme Court, Disney would have probably lost! About a year after our victory, in 1985, The Happiest Place on Earth quietly dropped the policy altogether, claiming they couldn't tell "who was dancing with whom."  They denied that the Exler v. Disneyland victory had anything to do with their decision.  Like, duh. "In 1995 Judge Ross resigned from the bench of the Superior Court, Orange County, California. Rumors flew that he was driven out by interests no less powerful than Disneyland and the Republican Party. A couple of years later I was contacted by Andrew Exler, who wanted to express his personal undying appreciation to Judge Ross for his verdict against Disneyland. Exler & Shawn Elliott, both openly gay, has been thrown out of Disneyland for dancing together. The suit came before Judge Ross. Jim understood the incendiary nature of the case in ultra conservative Orange County. Jim also was up for reelection soon, and Jim was a Democrat. Jim's tactical smarts came into play. "I knew I could empanel a jury. But I didn't have to accept their verdict. I could rule as I chose. Disney attorneys were happy with the jury, because the people came from Orange County. Exler and Elliott were happy, because there would be a record of the voice of the people. With the jury in place, the case went forward." The moment came for the jury to render a verdict. They deliberated quickly, and almost immediately judged against Disneyland. Now Judge Ross had to rule. "I didn't have to think about it too much," Jim said later. "Civil rights had been violated, and I ruled against Disney." The forces of power went into motion. Charges were brought against Judge Ross that he was selling his book from the bench, and that he should be removed. The frivolous nature of the charges were deceptive. "If I made a mistake," Jim admitted later, "it was not in treating the charges more seriously early in the process." To preserve his pension, Jim opted for retirement. I asked him if he ever regretted his decision against Disney. "I got a lot of hate mail afterward that was regretful. But the actual decision I never regretted " I pressed him. "Why not?" "It was about civil rights. Someone had to stand up for the little guy." Disney drops policy

Curb & Manahan
1985-Rosemary Curb and Nancy Manahan authors of Nuns Breaking Silence  were thrown out of their Dublin hotel in Ireland after appearing on "The Late Late Show" on which they identified themselves as lesbians and former nuns.

1986-Feminist/Lesbian folk singer Alix Dobkin performed at the First Unitarian Church on 13th East in Salt Lake City.

1986 Pee Wee's Playhouse debuts on CBS's Saturday Morning Kids lineup.The show starred Paul Reubens living in his wild and wacky Playhouse, full of talking chairs, animals, robots, and other puppet and human characters. The show became a hit, and during its time on the air, Pee-wee's Playhouse garnered 15 Emmy Awards.

Marty Pollock
 aka Marita Gayle
1987- Anne and Marci presented “Brutal-101- Roast the Toast” as a benefit at the INBETWEEN. Empress VI Marita Gayle was the subject of the roast.

1992-Two Gay men in Manhattan were attacked by at least twenty-five teenagers. New York City mayor David Dinkins condemned the attack and urged state and federal legislation to prevent gay bashing.

1993-Washington DC repealed its sodomy law through the efforts of activist Frank Kameny

David S Young
1994 The Salt Lake Tribune Letter: Not Upstanding Utah District Judge David Young's college friend and Salt Lake attorney, Phil Fishler, calls Judge Young "a fine judge and an upstanding man" (The Salt Lake Tribune, September 4).  I don't know what is fine or upstanding about sentencing a murderer to as little as 12 months in prison. Judge Young and his supporters would have us believe that he had only the best intentions for giving a one-to-six-year reduced
David Nelson
sentence to admitted homophobic killer David Thacker. Thacker pleaded guilty in May to hunting down and killing Douglas Koehler, a 31-year-old gay Salt Lake City businessman, last year. It appears that Judge Young had his best intentions only for Thacker, not the victim, the victim's family or other Utahns who know that Thacker could be walking free as soon as next summer. DAVID NELSON Salt Lake City

1996 Friday, ALL WOMEN'S EVE FESTIVAL SUNDAY AT REDBUTTE The fourth annual All Women's Eve Festival will be Sunday, Sept. 15, at the Red Butte Gardens on the University of Utah campus. The music and arts festival runs from 10 a.m. to 7 p.m.This year's performers include Lee Thomas, guitar; Lee Mortensen, poetry; Julie Phillips, acoustic folk; Kathryn
Kathryn Warner
Warner,
acoustic folk; Beth York and Barbara Esther performing feminist classics;Veiled Visions Belly Dancing; Elsie West, healing new age music; Starlette Company Ballet; Born Yesterday, traditional folk and spiritual; Megan Peters, blues, jazz and rock; Lisa Marie and the Co-Dependents, cover tunes and dance music; and Sweet Loretta, with "spirited world music sound."At 11:55 a.m., author Carol Lynn Pearson will speak on the power and creative expression of women. At 1:10 p.m., potter Lily Johnson will speak on using
Renee Rinaldi
art for healing
. At 4:25 p.m., Renee Rinaldi, director of the Utah Stonewall Center, will speak on community service and volunteerism. Men, women and children are invited to attend and to bring drums and rattles for the celebration that ends the festival. Tickets are $8 in advance, available at A Woman's Place Bookstore in Foothill Village, Blue Marble at 1400 S. 1100 East in Salt Lake City, and through the Ogden's Women's Group at 625-1660. At the door, tickets are $10. _© 1998 Deseret News Publishing Co

1997: YWCA Honorees Did More Than Survive Life's Trials YWCA Honors Women Who Met Challenge Byline: BY PATTY HENETZ THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE   For the first time since she was diagnosed with  AIDS seven years ago, Barb Barnhart missed a speaking engagement. One of the six women who
on Friday received Outstanding Achievement Awards at the annual YWCA Leader Luncheon, Barnhart was in the hospital. Just days ago, she was in critical condition when her liver, kidneys and lungs shutdown. She pulled through, but remains inconstant, extreme pain from peritonitis. She planned on coming to ``probably give away, way, way short speech,'' she said Wednesday. ``This is cool, but I feel kind of inadequate. They call it `Women of Courageous Actions.' This is called living through it. This is the only way I know how to do it. I just kind of feel like, what's the point if you're not living fully? That's not being courageous. Anybody can do it. I look at all the things people have done for me.'' That message -- that courage is in every person, that everyone suffers adversity at sometime, that the support of family, friends and community makes it possible for us all to get by-- was a constant with the rest of this year's award recipients: Laura Boardman, Elizabeth Hammond, Brandy Farmer, Anne Erickson and Eileen Hallet Stone.   Barnhart, a nurse and health-care provider, tested positive for HIV in 1990 during a routine screening. She was 26. HIV quickly progressed to AIDS. Then she heard that her step father also had AIDS, and she knew where she had gotten it: from the man who sexually abused her from age 9 to age 15. She has been critically ill for years. But as she says, she chose to live with AIDS, not just die from it. ``I've always been of the philosophy that if you have something you don't like, you fight. I don't know what I'd do any different,'' she said.   Ann Stromness, coordinator of the Journey Home program for people in the latter stages of   AIDS, estimates Barnhart has reached 35,000 Utahns in her AIDS-education efforts. Stromness and Utah AIDS  Foundation outreach coordinator Kim Russo accepted Barnhart's award, given in the human services category. ``We need to do a reality check that we, too, are at risk,'' Stromness told the 600 women and men at the luncheon. ``This is why Barb's work is so important.''   Each of the women who received the achievement awards were honored for their important work and for overcoming adversity.Salt Lake Tribune Page: D1 

1998-Sunday-2nd Annual Rainbow Run/Walk held at Memory Grove. Proceeds went to the Gay and Lesbian Community Center of Utah


2001  - On the 700 Club, TV evangelists Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson say that pagans, abortionists, feminists, gays and lesbians, the ACLU, and the People For the American Way were partially to blame for 9/11. "Television evangelists Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson, two of the most prominent voices of the religious right, said liberal civil liberties groups, feminists, homosexuals and abortion rights supporters bear partial responsibility for Tuesday's terrorist attacks because their actions have turned God's anger against America. "God continues to lift the curtain and allow the enemies of America to give us probably what we deserve," said Falwell, appearing yesterday on the Christian Broadcasting Network's "700 Club," hosted by Robertson. "Jerry, that's my feeling," Robertson responded. "I think we've just seen the antechamber to terror. We haven't even begun to see what they can do to the major population." Falwell said the American Civil Liberties Union has "got to take a lot of blame for this," again winning Robertson's agreement: "Well, yes." Then Falwell broadened his blast to include the federal courts and others who he said were "throwing God out of the public square." He added: "The abortionists have got to bear some burden for this because God will not be mocked. And when we destroy 40 million little innocent babies, we make God mad. I really believe that the pagans, and the abortionists, and the feminists, and the gays and the lesbians who are actively trying to make that an alternative lifestyle, the ACLU, People for the American Way -- all of them who have tried to secularize America -- I point the finger in their face and say, 'You helped this happen.' " - Washington Post (09/14/01) "I am deeply saddened that in the wake of this week's devastating terrorist attacks, Religious Right political leaders Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell have chosen the path of division rather than unity. Below is a partial transcript of the 700 Club television program from Thursday, September 13, 2001." - People for the American Way (09/13/01)

Chad Keller
2002 Chad Keller to Stephanie Pappas:  Stephanie, I am sure that in some way I have put our friendship in some sort of jeopardy with my firm stand regarding the potential merger of Pride by the Center. There are several issues that are being overlooked, and a community that is not being listened too.  As I prepare to be thrown out of Pride for my vocal opposition to this plan hatched my a mutual member of our groups, I would like you and I to sit down, and discuss the issues of the merger, the issues of Pride, and what I have seen in the Center through the eyes of members of our community.  I have lost a lot of belief in the Center from this and other circumstances surrounding my participation at and with the Center.  It has compounded it as I have listened to members of the community.  Perhaps our discussion can clarify some things for me, and give you insight into what I and others are seeing. Perhaps then we can together find a solution that is better for both Pride and the Center than merging the two, or we could come to an agreeable understanding to protect our an old friendship.  I am available at anytime for you and I to meet By the way...how the heck are you?  In Pride, and respect  Chad Keller 
  • Stephanie Pappas to Chad Keller : Chad - First of all I want you to know that regardless
    Stephanie Pappas
    of the Pride/Center situation, I don't have any strained personal feelings toward you or any other members of the Pride/Center boards. Business is business and personal relationships are a completely different issue.  I would be more than happy to sit down with you and discuss the pertinent issues surrounding Pride as you see them.  I have kept relatively quiet on the issue but have gotten a lot of different perspectives on the pros and cons of merging the two entities.  I also think it may be helpful for you to hear my take of the merger.  I am available next week so let’s pick some time and get together.  Would day or night work better for you.  Let me know. Steph. 
  • Chad Keller to Craig Miller: I just want you to know that all of this going on will not as far as I am concerned will not affect our friendship as far as I am concerned.  I do feel a little beat up by Sherry [Booth] and Darien [Hobbs}.  I have to laugh as I feel the only reason either of them participate in the forum right now is that they are afraid of what I might say.  Neither have every really shown to me a genuine concern for the community accept for that which effects their own existence and circle of friends.  I watch sadly how board and how neither wanted to be their last night, or last month. I cant change the community....all I can do is make it think, make it want to be better, and do better.  IF that at times has given me the reputation of a Cold Hearted Calculated Bitch then so be it. The legacy I leave, that any of us leave will be reflected in history.  Does it bother me that I may be forever know as a trouble making bitch, yeah sure, but at one point wasn’t Ben William, Rocky O’Donovan, and other know with the same reputation, I think if I remember right on occasion and in the past you weren’t always so reserved. The biggest reason, Craig that I choose not to go through another board bashing is it not necessary for me or the board.  I think it was best summed up for me the day I got the letter that Pride as an organization is more evil and vindictive than the RCGSE [Royal Court of the Golden Spike Empire] ever has been.  Also there is no need for me to point out any of the issues from the other stand point.  I only managed to stop the Quick and Quiet merger.  I pray that Fate intervenes, but it may be too late.  A group of weary travelers just want to unload the burden. I’ve also cried enough over the disappointment in people that I truly valued, and over an organization that I and many care and worry about on a regular basis.  I have learned that there is no way to control perception, no way to control emotion, and no way to dictate behavior.  Sherry will spend the rest of her life in a very sad existence continuing to try to do so.  (needs to be a little less of a boss, and a lot more leader) I look at it this way.  There aren’t the votes to keep me there.  But Pride will have to say “leave”, and parting will present an new set of challenges for myself, you, and their rest.  It is sad that we continue to look past the actions of the heart, and take personal offence to actions that are not necessarily directed at the individual. A friend sums it up for me the best with this statement “there are those who will waltz in, think they know how to solve everything.  You must continue to be your curious and questioning outlandish self...You must never find use for those who in the community earn their paycheck or recognition without any community input.  You after all did warn us of Kim [Russo]...sadly we did not listen.  Take heed to watch for those that profess to know the right path and that make grand gestures stating it is the best for the community...Be aware of the less fortunate and those that are not the norm...play the game but do not succumb to the politics....choose your own path your own destiny.... as you have always....and community will embrace you both now and in the future." Craig what ever is in the cards I will forever be there for you....and I may really start to irritate you....and others.....know it is not personal...I’m just doing what my heart tells me....watching out for the less fortunate, the have not's, the will never be's, the average person afraid to take a stand.  It is programmed in my journey. 
2005 Tuesday From: "Robert R. Massey" To: ben@slmetro.com Subject: Robert Joseph Dover Ben You mentioned Joe Dover (Spike?) in your recent Metro article. Joe Dover was a good friend and roommate at Upsala College. I had been  in touch with him after he moved to Utah to do grad work at BYU but  then he must have changed addresses. I subsequently lost touch with him. I  would like to touch base with him again. I hope all is well with him. I was actually in Provo on business for a full week about 3 or 4 years  ago and I tried to locate him then to no avail. I couldn't find a listing in  any of the phone books but that doesn't surprise me since I know Joe was living modestly and may not have had a phone. I also poked around the BYU Library to see if anyone knew of him but I came up empty there also. Do you have any information on his whereabouts or how I might be able  to  contact him. Any information would be appreciated. Bob Massey Ventura, California
  • Ben Edgar Williams wrote: I am sorry I can't help you. I only knew Joe when we both worked for the Salt Lake Triangle back in the late 1980's. He was an editor for Satu Servigna at the time. When the paper folded I lost track of him. We  weren't in the same circle of friends and he was kind of a recluse as I recall. Perhaps if you contacted Affirmation or GAYBYU and posted that you are seeking information on him someone there might be able to help. GAYBYU is a Yahoo Groupsite and has nearly 700 members as I last recall. The local chapter of Affirmation might have some knowledge of his whereabouts if he is still in the state and ventures out. > Good Luck Ben Williams
  • From: "Robert R. Massey" To: "Ben Edgar Williams" Subject: Re: Robert Joseph Dover “Ben Thanks for at least pointing me in a couple of new directions. Maybe something will pan out. You are right, he was a bit of a recluse but there was also a wonderfully devilish side to him if you got to know him. When he came out I think he still carried allot of guilt. It's not surprising since he was raised Catholic. In one of my last conversations with him he was sure he had alienated our small group of friends from the Upsala days by telling them at a reunion he was gay. The truth was that nobody really cared. He was still a great friend and has not been forgotten. I would appreciate it if you would save my address in case you come up with any other ideas as to how I might track him down. Bob Massey
2005 Also we are hosting a screening of the premiere episode of Transgeneration on September 13th, co-hosted by the GLBTCCU, Equality Utah, and the Utah AIDS Foundation.  It will be screened in the Union Theater at 7 PM, Free admission, and discussion held afterwards for those who wish to stay. 

  • 2005 Tuesday Sep 13th - Free Screening of TransGeneration. University Union Theater ( 7pm ) TransGeneration is a groundbreaking 8-part verite- documentary series that captures a year in the life of four transgender college students. The series follows four unique individuals, two male-to-females and two female-to-males as they struggle to transition from one gender to the other in the midst of a grueling school year. From working-class campuses to private colleges steeped in tradition, we follow these four students as they juggle the pressures of college life, academia and family expectations with their own life-changing transitions. Idealistic and impassioned, these four young adults embark on a journey of self-discovery and in the process re-define gender for their generation. Panel Discussion to follow the screening. 
2017  SALT LAKE CITY — The Utah Supreme Court is considering a challenge to state law governing surrogacy from a married gay couple. In arguments the state’s top court heard from the lawyer representing the couple, who were denied the chance to have a baby through a surrogate by a judge last year. Utah law dictates a surrogacy can only be used if there is proof a mother cannot conceive or faces medical harm. The law discriminates against same-sex couples, their attorney argued. This is believed to be the first challenge to such a law following the U.S. Supreme Court’s historic ruling on same-sex marriage in 2015.

2018   Many of the bright rainbow flags representing Provo Pride week across the city have gone missing or have been vandalized in areas of the city according to Provo Police reports.

Jerilynn Pool, Provo Pride board member, said the flags are part of a special flag project to raise funds for Pride Week. The project began in Salt Lake City, then Ogden, Provo and St. George next week. People would rent flags to place in front of their homes or businesses in exchange for a $15 donation. “Provo is the only one to have flags stolen,” Pool said. “This is the first time.” She added, ”We’ve replaced flags and will put more up.” Provo Pride celebrations began six years ago in Provo and according to Pool, there has never been this kind of negative action or reaction to the LBGTQ community. Pool said members of the Pride organization are very frustrated, but many of them expect it. “It may be a couple of bad apples in Provo, but it doesn’t feel like that,” Pool said. She added she has personal concerns for young people who are afraid to come out and see these kinds of defacing and vandalism and are scared to trust their neighbors or feel safe. According to Sgt. Nisha King of the Provo Police Department, four separate reports on stolen flags and vandalism have been reported in this week. Pride members said that an announcement sign at the Community Congregational Church at 200 North and University Avenue was also vandalized overnight Thursday. The sign was announcing special services celebrating Pride Week. According to King, a report had yet to be filed on the overnight problems at the church. Four separate incidents have been reported. According to police reports, they have no information on a suspect or suspects involved in any of the cases. Several businesses in the downtown area are displaying the 3-foot by 5-foot flags during work hours, but bring them in at night. The flags have an estimated value of $15 per flag, according to police reports. The flags have been stolen between the hours of 11 p.m. and 6 a.m. in the Provost and South Provost neighborhoods, according to Pool. Provo Pride week will culminate Saturday with a full day of activities, food and entertainment at the Historic Utah County Courthouse grounds. Daily Herald reporter Genelle Pugmire 

No comments:

Post a Comment